Russia’s presence in the G8 is one of those historical accidents that defy conventional logic. It is not one of the world’s leading economic powers – the original and still most important criterion for membership. Its influence on global affairs has declined to near- insignificance. And its standing as a democracy, never convincing, is at its lowest since the fall of the Soviet Union fourteen years ago. Judged by any objective standard, Russia is the least ‘deserving’ member of the group, with a number of outsiders – China, India, Brazil – having far stronger claims for inclusion.