Don’t blame the scientists

Politicians should lead, not hide behind experts, writes Calum Inverarity.

The World Today Published 1 June 2020 Updated 27 September 2020 3 minute READ

Calum Inverarity

Senior Researcher, Open Data Institute

Throughout the coronavirus pandemic, the British public have become familiar with the government repeatedly saying that its decisions are ‘led by the science’. Ministers have used these words to respond to media questions on a wide variety of issues: from the actions the government took – or failed to take – to contain the virus, to the coun- try’s economic prospects.

A simple, reductive message is not unknown in British politics. The soundbite ‘Get Brexit done’ is credited with helping the current government secure its parliamentary majority last December. But it has become glaringly apparent that such simple messaging is of limited use when dealing with a public health crisis of the magnitude of COVID-19.

Contrary to reassuring the public, the repeated deference to ‘the science’ has served not only to highlight the failings in early preparedness for the pandemic, but to reignite tensions that exist at the boundary between policymaking and scientific expertise.

Subscribe to read all issues

Articles from the current issue are free to read by all, the archive is exclusive to magazine subscribers and our members. Subscribe or become a member to view articles from the archive.