Spying on the spies

Edward Lucas assesses a spook’s polemic on counter-intelligence failings

The World Today

Published 26 July 2019

Updated 6 November 2020 — 3 minute READ

Edward Lucas

Non-resident Senior Fellow, Center for European Policy Analysis (CEPA)

To Catch a Spy: The Art of Counterintelligence

James Olson, Georgetown University Press, £22.50

Counter-intelligence officers are the poor relations of the spy world. Their colleagues in mainstream espionage go out in the field to steal secrets and delight their bosses. The spy-catchers get in the way.

Their job is to ask awkward questions – how can we be sure that this new source is trustworthy? – and to set and enforce annoying rules. Recruits must be screened, a process that is slow and intrusive. Experience and success do not mean you escape scrutiny, including by polygraph, or lie detector, which in the American system plays a big role. Information must be properly compartmentalized, which slows things down.

Access the archive

The current issue is open access with previous editions reserved for our members and magazine subscribers.

Subscribe